· MLL 2010 Cascade Rookie of the Year
· Tewaaraton Recipient
· MLL All-Star (2011, 2013)
· Team USA (2010, 2014)
2015: Played in 12 games scoring 10 goals and 12 assists for the New York Lizards. Won the 2015 MLL Championship with the Lizards
2014: Appeared in 12 games scoring 18 goals and adding 7 assists with the Lizards. Had 12 groundballs on the season as well.
2013: Played in 13 games for Rochester. Scored 15 goals, 1 2 pt goal and 20 assists in the season for a total 36 points.
2012: Played in 12 games for the Rattlers and scored 15 goals and 16 assists. Picked up 11 groundballs as well.
2011: Selected to the All-MLL team and led the league in statistical scoring and assists. Scored 29 goals and 21 assists. Was an MLL All-Star.
2010: Started his career with the Chicago Machine appearing in 7 games. In those games, Crotty scored 11 goals and had 13 assists as well as nine groundballs.
Crotty was a three time all-American at Duke as well as the recipient of the Tewaaraton Trophy his senior year. While at Duke, Crotty also helped lead the Blue Devils to a National Championship in 2010. Crotty finished his career at Duke with 92 goals and 147 assists for a total of 239 points.